Autumn/Winter 2008

– Autumn/Winter 2008

Contextual Essays

Artists

Events, Works, Exhibitions

For a Populist Cinema: On Hito Steyerl’s November and Lovely Andrea

Pablo Lafuente

Tags: Chris Marker, Jean-Louis Comolli, Jean-Luc Godard

In the early years of the French Revolution, the red flag was a sign of martial law, displayed by the gendarmerie to warn civilians that if they didn't disperse they would be fired on. But in July 1792 the Jacobin journalist Jean-Louis Carra printed on the flag, in black letters, 'Martial Law of the Sovereign People Against Rebellion by the Executive Power', thus making the red flag the flag of revolution.1

Since that moment, and for most of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, the colour red has symbolised the fight against oppression and the pursuit of a social organisation based on equality. Today, however, after the fall of the Berlin Wall, red is again seen as a sign of warning, in contrast to the colour green understood as that of nature, of openness, of the originary and the authentic - and perhaps, too, of the market. What perhaps is the colour's key note - disruption - still remains, but what is being disrupted has changed: if originally it symbolized an end to disorder (that of the revolutionary masses) and later an end to a certain order (of the State, or of capitalism), today it is again used, at least in the West, to warn against disorders (of illegal immigrants, of terror attacks and non-Western values) which threaten the social and productive relations of late capitalism.

This story of changes in the meaning of a sign, of its appropriation and subsequent loss by a certain position, is key to understanding how individuals organise (or disorganise) their life in common. Both social structures and political struggles can be partially accounted for by means of such